The information in this study section
is
extremely important for your further studies in law, and also for
your practice one day. This
section will teach you
where to find the answers to legal questions and to present them correctly.
After
studying this section
you
will be able to:
•find sources
of the law in a library
• present
research results correctly
• present
footnotes and a bibliography correctly
Introduction
Legal studies and legal questions require
research. Sometimes you will have to read a court case or an Act and at times you will have
to do a more in-depth study. You will also have to consult a number of sources in
order to finalise an argument. This study unit and the previous one are
one. The
one should not be read without the other. Sources of
the law are divided in two main categories namely primary and secondary
sources.
Primary sources:
Common law, legislation, court cases and custom
Secondary sources:
Textbooks, journal articles and the Internet
Apart from finding sources legal research
also entails that your research results should be presented correctly. You should not be
guilty of plagiarism.
Plagiarism: You
commit plagiarism when you take the words, ideas or thoughts of
another person
and present them as your own. It is a form of theft which includes a
number of academic
activities.
Many universities use an online program Turnitin to
detect plagiarism.
This programme compares the work of a student to a database of
more than
4,5 milliard pages from the internet, newspapers, journals, textbooks and
other students’
work. This programme ‘‘marks’’ parts of a student’s work similar to
that in
other sources.
Examples of plagiarism include the
following:
•
the
direct repeating or copying of paragraphs, sentences, one sentence or a
meaningful part
of a sentence;
•the
repeating
of thoughts, research results, statistics, designs and so on, without
giving recognition
to the original designer or researcher.
•
the
paraphrasing of another’s work, with small changes, but the essence kept;
•
to
base your arguments on a specific idea or interpretation which is not yours
without giving
recognition to the person whose idea it is;
•to
copy
and paste from numerous sources and present it as your original work;
•
to
pretend that you have done the work alone whereas you did it with someone
else;
•
to
submit a part on the whole piece of work of another student;
•
if
you submit an original piece of work with the correct references for two
different subjects;
•
to be
dishonest in an exam by either using crip notes or to copy from a fellows
student.
Finding
primary sources
Primary sources are important because
they are the law at any given moment. They have authoritative value which is more than
pure persuasive value. Primary sources are common law, legislation, court cases and custom.
PLEASE NOTE: In
this module we only teach you where to find the sources of
the law
and basically how to read them. In (Introduction
to Law) you will
get more
information on the different sources of our legal system.
1. Finding legislation
REMEMBER: Legislation includes the
following: national legislation (Parliament),provincial legislation
(Provincial legislatures) and local legislation (City
Councils).
Legislation (an
Act/a Statute) is published in the Government Gazette (see the example
on the previous
hand outs. Certain publishers
like Juta and Butterworths also
publish legislation. The Butterworths
publication is
a loose-leaf
publication which
is updated frequently. The Juta publication, Juta’s
Statutes
of South Africa,
is published annually. Volume 1 is the index to the legislation published
for a particular year. As an example we will use the Butterworth
index to
help you with your search.
The index is divided into three sections:
• An
alphabetical list of titles;
• the
subject list;
• the
chronological list of acts
Refer to hand-outs!!!
example
Your brother left home. Weeks later you hear
that he has died. He was involved in a
hit and run accident. An unknown motorist
found his body hours later. He was
declared brain dead when he arrived at
the hospital. You, an attorney, visit the
hospital to find out what has happened to
his body. They tell you that nearly all his
vital organs (heart, liver, kidneys,
pancreas, skin and bone) were used for
transplantations. You are extremely angry
and want to know whether there is an
Act regulating such practices.
1. Where will you begin to look for
relevant legislation?
2. Which Act is relevant?
3. Is there another Act you have to look
at?
4. What does the Act say about what
happened with your brother?
2.Finding court
cases
When you do research as above it is not
sufficient reading only the Act. You will have to find out whether there are court cases in
which the courts interpreted the Act. It is therefore very
important to know where to look for relevant court cases.
You may follow the
following process:
• If
you have the reference to the case: Kriel v Hochstetter House (Edms) Bpk 1988(1) SA 220, you will find the case in
volume (1) of 1988, of the South African Law Reports on
page 220.
• If
you have the name of one of the parties or both you can find the case reference
by
consulting the
indexes to the court cases, for example: the Index to the Southern
African Law
Reports 1828–1946, and Noter-up;
Butterworth’s Consolidated Index and Noter-up to the South African Law Reports and Juta’s
Index and Annotations to
the South
African Law Reports. In the ‘‘Cases Reported’’ (Butterworth) or the
‘‘Table
of Cases’’ (Juta)
which form part of these indexes you will find a list of
reported cases.
•If
you have no reference information but you want to find out whether there is any
court case
on a specific topic or if there is a court case based on a certain Act you
should also
consult the indexes. It contains subject as well as legislation indexes.
•Write
down the scenario
in the example
above and try to
find a court case on the illegal
transplantation of
human organs.
Finding common law
•South
Africa does not have one specific book (or code) containing a list of all the
possible crimes. Therefore, we say South African law is not codified. To determine
whether a crime has been committed you cannot only look at legislation
or court
cases. You will have to consult common law as well. You will find the
common law
in the writings of the old authors from Roman and Roman-Dutch times.
Example
Let us look at the example of your
brother’s organs being used without permission again. We
have seen that the Act is clear concerning who should give permission for
organs to be
removed from a body in order to transplant it. But, to whom do the organs
belong when
they are removed from a body is not clear. Because the Act does not
specifically address
this issue, we have to fall back on the common law sources to try
and find
an answer. We therefore have to read what the Roman and Roman-Dutch
authors said
about the ownership of body parts. You may consult translated texts of
these writers
unless you can read Latin or Dutch. You can find these early writings in
the archives
of a library.
According to the common law a res
is a
thing outside a person which can exist independently and
it can belong to someone and be controlled by that person. A human
body or
body parts are not outside a person but part of the person. The Roman-Dutch
writers were,
therefore, of the opinion that a person is not a master of his own body(dominus
membrorum
suorum)
and
can therefore not own his body. Because you cannot own your body you cannot give permission
to have parts removed from your body. The body and its parts are classified
as res
extra commercium.
In
other words
body parts
are things outside commerce. Body parts were viewed as res
nullius. In other
words,
they belonged to no one.
This problem is addressed nowadays by
asking a patient to sign a consent form on admission in a
hospital that the hospital may dispose of any body parts being removed
during an
operation.
(We conclude with this: All we wanted to
do was to indicate the working of the common law — there are other relevant arguments
on this same topic but they fall outside the
scope of this module.)
Finding secondary sources
REMEMBER: Secondary sources have
persuasive authority only. Law is not created through secondary
sources. Secondary sources are influenced by personal arguments
and views
which are not necessarily correct.
Books
The content of law books can easily
become out
dated. It
is therefore very important to note the date of publication. The date of
publication appears on the title page or on the back of the title page. It is also important
to look at the place of publication so that you can be sure which
legal system
is applicable.
Nowadays nearly
all libraries have electronic resources.
Journal articles
When you do research you will have to
consult journal articles as well. In the previous section it was explained
to you how to read an article. Reread that section. Note that
we are
not talking
about weekly general magazines; we are referring to academic publications.
Academics who
have done research on certain topics publish their results from time to time.
Useful search engines and websites for
legal research:-
South
Africa
Southern African Legal Information
Institute: http://www.saflii.org [Free
access to legal
information in Southern Africa.]
SAGNU Index [South African Government of
National Unity]: http://www.polity.org.za
University of the Witwatersrand: http://www.law.wits.ac.za
[Many
useful South
African law links from the Wits Law
Faculty Home Page.]
THINKING
CRITICALLY
The skills we have discussed so far
require an element of critical thinking. Whether you are reading, researching,
listening or making notes, you have to ask yourself “WHAT DO I REALLY THINK
ABOUT THIS?”
It
involves careful thorough questioning. It will help you to solve problems and
gain an objective, reasonable understanding of things. Its also a tool for your
career. Please note we are not referring to negative or argumentative remarks.
Critical
thinking and the law
We say critical thinking is important in
law because as legal practitioner you will have to assess the value or the
validity of a particular issue in law, legal opinion or point of view. You will
be expected to defend or oppose , use legal arguments substantiated or
supported by legal authority (cases and
legislation)
At times you will be faced to argue that
the law is wrong and you will be asked what should be changed in order to
better suit society. In these circumstances
it is important to remember that the law is made by people and can be
changed and reformed.
Critical thinking means being prepared to
think objectively about the law and to argue for its reform, rather than to
accept the law as it is.
Secondly, critical thinking will be
important when you have to understand complex forms of legal argument. Legal
arguments, especially in new areas of law, do not only rely on legal
authorities such as precedent or legislation, but on arguments about social
values and public policy.
NB!!! We are not talking about an
argument one would have with a brother or sister when you disagree…. This kind
of argument maybe emotional and aggressive and never quite resolves a dispute.
We are referring to an argument in a legal or an academic sense. That is a
reasoned and a logical way of setting out your position or where you stand on a
certain issue.
See when you have an argument you are
trying to persuade the other person or people of your viewpoint.
Critical thinking is important because it
will help you to formulate your own arguments well. It will also help you to
criticise and evaluate the arguments of lawyers, authors and judges.
Its important to note that an argument
may be a good one even though you don’t agree. To think critically means being
able to evaluate whether an argument is good or bad, no matter whether you
agree with the arguments conclusion or not.
Critical
thinking when listening or reading
You are expected or required to
understand what you have heard or read and be ready to argue for it or against
it and apply it in different situations. You are expected to think critically
about everything you hear or read.
When you think critically about something
you are listening to or reading, think about it and question
1. Its content 2. its context 3. the
arguments raised and the authority for these argument or ideas 4. its
structure, language and style
1. content- you need to identify the main ideas in order
to establish the content of what is being covered in the text. When you have
done so then you need to think critically about the main ideas e.g. ask
yourself the following questions:
•Do I
understand the ideas presented?
•Do I
agree with the points or idea being made?
•Can I
think of any situation in which the idea presented wouldn’t make sense.
•Have
I been provided with reasons or evidence for believing the ideas presented
2. Context- by looking at the
context we are referring to the
background and history behind something. To establish the context ask yourself
the ff
questions:
•Who
is the author
•When
was the text written or published
•Does
the text show a political or ideological learning
•Is
there controversy surrounding this particular area of law. E.g. the case of
death penalty, corporal punishment or abortion.
•And
etc. refer to pg. 149
3. Argument- you should evaluate the
strength or weakness of the argument presented and then decide how persuasive
it is. An argument consists of claims or proposition, reasons and a conclusion.
The authors argument may not always be immediately clear and you may need to
interpret the text in order to summaries the argument.
To establish an argument you may need to
ask yourself some questions…. And they are found on page 149 bottom of the page
to 153
4. Structure, language and style- as you
saw on chapter 3 “sources of law” the structure, language and style of various
sources of law may differ considerably and it is important to be able to work
with and understand different kinds of legal text.
ADVOCATING
THE COURT ROOM
üThe
South African court System
üAdvocacy:
the skill of oral persuasion
üUnderstanding
moot court and mock trials
The South African court system
The
court structure
Section 166 of the constitution of the
Republic of South Africa 1996, outlines and explains the following court
structures in South Africa:-
•Constitutional court (highest courts in all constitutional
matters) and the Supreme court of appeal
(highest court in all matters except constitutional matters)
•High courts (provincial
and local divisions)
•Other specialised superior courts:
Labour court, labour appeal court, land claims court, special income tax court,
competition appeal court special consumer court and electoral court
•Lower courts(magistrates
courts) Regional courts and district courts (each district court also functions
as a children's court and a maintenance court
•Other specialised lower courts:
small claims court, court of chiefs and headmen, equality court, water
tribunal, community court, divorce court etc.
Constitutional court
•Highest
court in all constitutional matters
•The
court deals or decides in constitutional matters
•Makes
final decision on whether the matter is a constitutional matter
Origin
•Constitution
‘96
•S167
(together with schedule 6 of the constitution)
Jurisdiction
•The
court only deals with constitutional matters.
•A
constitutional matter is defined in S167 “ any issue involving the
interpretation, protection or enforcement of the constitution”
•Regulates
processes and develop common law
•Court
of 1st instance
There are 6 matters that fall under the
exclusive jurisdiction:-
1.Disputes
between organs of states in the national or provincial area concerning
constitutional status, powers or functions of those organs;
2.The
constitutionality of whether it is legal and fair of any parliamentary or
provincial Bill
3.Applications
that a provincial Act or Act of parliament is unconstitutional
4.The
constitutionality of any amendment in the constitution
5.Whether
the parliament or the president has failed to fulfil a constitutional
obligation,
6.The
certification or approval of a provincial constitution
Presiding officers:
•Chief
justice, Deputy Chief and nine other judges.(in 2005Justice Pius Langa was
appointed as chief justice and thereafter Arthur Chaskalson) who are appointed by the president.
•Matter
is decided on a minimum of 8 judges
On page 264-267 you will read on your on
your own please know this for exam purposes.
The people who you will work with in
courtJ
•The
legal practitioners who appear in court are called attorneys
or advocates. The
presiding
officer is
the person who sits on the bench.
An Attorney
•Is
a general practitioner (GP) of the legal profession. Minimum requirement for
admission as an attorney is an LLB degree. Attorneys must serve a period of
articled clerkship and also pass the
attorneys admission examination set by the Law Society of SA. Attorneys can
practice on their own or in a partnership, they can appear in lower courts….
And can apply for a right of appearance in the high court.
No comments:
Post a Comment