When reading a court case one needs to
take certain aspects into consideration. In this section we
will use, as examples, three court cases to explain the structure of a reported
court case.
We believe that this will help you a great deal in understanding most of the
aspects of a
court case.
Please take note that these court cases are
merely examples, and
that other
court cases slightly differ from them. You should also remember that there are
three types
of reported court decisions; namely: civil cases, criminal cases and
constitutional cases
The following cases are going to be used
as examples:
(1) S v Makua 1993 (1) SACR 160 (T): This is a
criminal case.
(2) Molefe v Mahaeng 1999 (1) SA 562 (SCA):
This is a
civil case.
(3) Ex Parte Addleson 1948
(2) SA 16 (E): This is a motion application where only one person/party
is
involved.
Case
name
Any reference to a particular case will
always start with the name of that case; that is the names of the parties (or persons) involved in
the case. Look at our first example before reading further.
Can you identify the name in this case?
(1) S v Makua (The parties are: State v Accused)
This is an example of a criminal case. In
this type of a case (criminal case) the first party is always the ‘‘S’’; that is, the state. The
other party is the ‘‘accused’’. In our example the accused
is thus ‘‘Makua’’.
He was accused of driving a motor vehicle while the alcohol concentration
in his blood exceeded the permissible limit as prescribed by law.
The ‘‘v’’ stands for ‘‘versus’’ (or against).
Therefore, in this criminal case it was the issue or case between the state and the accused
party/person (that is, Makua)
You will notice that
in earlier criminal cases (that is, cases that were heard by our courts before1961) the
letter ‘‘R’’ was used instead of ‘‘S’’. Loosely, the ‘‘R’’ stands for the (royal)crown. In
other words the prosecutions during that period (before South Africa became
a Republic
in 1961) were instituted on behalf of the King or Queen of England. This is
because the
King or Queen of England had sovereignty over South Africa. Note,
further, that
‘‘R’’ refers to Latin ‘‘Rex’’ (which means King) or ‘‘Regina’’ (which
means Queen).
(2) Molefe v Mahaeng (The parties are: Plaintiff v Defendant
or Appellant vRespondent)
This case is an example of a civil case (i.e.
a
case between citizens). In this particular case an action proceeding was used. In action
proceedings the name of the plaintiff is given first, and followed by the defendant’s. Should
the matter be on appeal, the name of the appellant will
appear first, and followed by the respondent’s.
In this example, the matter
is heard
on appeal. We can say this because the case is heard before the SCA. The
‘‘SCA’’
in our case name stands for the Supreme Court of Appeal. Thus, the parties are
the appellant
(Molefe) and
the respondent (Mahaeng).
In action proceedings the procedure is
started by way of a summons. This procedure(that is,
action proceedings) is used when there is a fundamental difference between the
parties as
far as the facts of the case are concerned.
In our example, there is a
fundamental difference
in the sense that the parties differed on who caused the accident.
Molefe said
the accident was the result of Mahaeng’s negligence, and Mahaeng said
that he
was not negligent
(3) Ex parte Addleson
(The
parties are: Applicant and/or Respondent if any)
This case is another example of a civil case.
However, here the application proceeding has been
used. In application proceedings the Latin words ‘‘Ex parte’’ (in the
application)
appear before the applicant’s name. In other words, the name of the person
who is
bringing the application (the applicant’s name) immediately follows these Latin
words. With reference
to our example, Mr. Addleson
brought an application to be admitted as an advocate
In application proceedings, the procedure
is started by way of notice of motion. Unlike in action proceedings, this procedure (that
is, application proceeding) is used when there is no fundamental difference between the
parties as far as the facts of the case are concerned. The
parties, in other words, more or less agree on the facts of the case.
Usually one party, namely the applicant,
is involved, and it is that party who brings the application. If
there is another person who wants to object to the application, then that
person would
be indicated as the respondent.
Year
and volume
This aspect relates to the books or
bundles in which publishers report cases every year. These books
are normally called ‘‘reports’’. Thus, every year there are different
volumes wherein
reported cases or court decisions appear. You will realise that in a case
name a
year appears immediately after the names of the parties (in every case). It shows
the year
in which the case was reported.
Since in a particular year many cases may be
reported, it
becomes necessary for these cases to be reported in many books. This is
why many
books (usually called volumes) of reports are published every year. The
number in
brackets shows which volume of the report contains the case that one may be
looking for.
Let us look at our examples again:
(1) S v Makua 1993 (1) SACR
160 (T): This case can be found in the first volume of
1993.
(2) Molefe v Mahaeng 1999 (1) SA
562 (SCA): This case can be found in the first volume of
1999.
(3) Ex parte Addleson 1948
(2) SA 16
(E): This case can be found in the second volume of 1948.
Series
of law reports
There are numerous law reports that are
commercially published; and these are given different names.
These law reports are identified by the abbreviations of the different
names given
to them. In a case reference the abbreviations appear
after the date and
volume of
the report.
Thus, the letters that appear after the date
(or year) and volume of
the report
are an abbreviation of the name of the report. It is interesting to note that there
seems to be
a reason or reasons why the reports are published under different names. It
would also
appear that different reports would contain different types of cases
This will become clear if we look at our
examples again:
(1) S v Makua 1993 (1) SACR 160 (T) SACR —
South African Criminal Law Reports. Only criminal law cases would be
reported here.
This is the reason why S v
Makua was
reported in the SACR.
(2) Molefe v Mahaeng 1999 (1) SA 562 (SCA) SA —
South African Law Reports. This is comprehensive set of law reports and
covers a
variety of South African criminal, civil and constitutional cases.
(3) Ex parte Addleson 1948
(2) SA 16 (E) SA —
South African Law Reports.
CLR — Commercial Law Reports
SALLR — South African Labour Law Reports
BCLR — Butterworth’s Constitutional Law Reports
CC- constitutional court
It is important to note that:
•
not
all civil and criminal cases are reported. Only the ones (cases) that are
regarded as
important are.
•
no
magistrate’s court cases are reported.
•only
certain
decisions of the higher courts are reported.
•
all
constitutional cases are reported
The page where the report starts
We should, again, return to our examples
to deal with this aspect of case reference:
(1) S v Makua 1993 (1) SACR 160 (T):
This case starts on page 160.
(2) Molefe v Mahaeng 1999 (1) SA 562
(SCA): This case starts on page 562.
(3) Ex Parte Addleson 1948
(2) SA 16 (E):
This case starts on page 16.
The court where the case was decided
We may also look at our examples to
clarify this:
(1) S v Makua 1993 (1) SACR 160 (T):
This case was heard in the Transvaal Provincial
Division (T) of the High Court. The
Transvaal Provincial Division is in Pretoria
(‘‘Transvaal’’ comes from the pre-1994
situation when the RSA was divided into
only 4 provinces; Transvaal, Cape
Province, Natal and the Orange Free State.
Transvaal was roughly the region now
known as Gauteng, Mphumalanga,
Limpopo
and the North West Province). The court
of first instance was the magistrate’s court
in Middelburg (Mphumalanga). In
other words, this is the court where the case was
first heard. In this case the court a quo
is also the magistrate’s court, since this is the
court from where there was an appeal to
the Transvaal Provincial Division (see page
161J of the case).
Molefe v Mahaeng 1999 (1) SA 562 (SCA): This case was
heard in the Supreme
Court of
Appeal. The Supreme Court of Appeal is in Bloemfontein. The
court of
first instance
(where the case was first heard) was the magistrate’s court in Welkom(see
page
564F).
The court a quo (from where the case came to
the Supreme Court
of Appeal)
was the Provincial Division of the High Court of the Free State, because
there was
an appeal from the magistrate’s court to the High Court (see page 564I;p.
566J).
(3) Ex Parte Addleson 1948
(2) SA 16 (E): The Eastern Cape Provincial Division of the
High Court
is where this case was heard. This Division is in Grahamstown. The
case
concerns an
application to be admitted as an advocate. Such an application may only
be brought
in the High Court.
Therefore,
the court of first instance in this case is the Eastern Cape
Provincial Division of the High Court, because this is where the case
was first
heard. There is no court a quo because this case did not come from another
court.
Thus, you can see that the High Court can also sometimes be a court of first instance.
CC/KH :
Constitutional Court (Johannesburg)
SCA/HHA :
Supreme Court of Appeal (Bloemfontein). Replaces the Appellate
Division which
was abbreviated by ‘‘A’’
C/K :
Cape Provincial Division (Cape Town)
E/OK : Eastern Cape Provincial Division (Grahamstown)
SE/SOK :
South East Cape Provincial Division (Port Elizabeth)
N :
Natal Provincial Division (Pietermaritzburg)
D/D+C/D+K :
Durban and Coast Local Division (Durban)
NC/NK :
North Cape Division (Kimberley)
O :
Orange Free State Provincial Division (Bloemfontein)
T/TPD/TPA
:
Transvaal Provincial Division (Pretoria)
W/WLD/WPA
:
Witwatersrand Local Division (Johannesburg)
READING
AN ACT….
(a) Text
You approach an Act by reading the signed
text. In our example, the English text was signed by the President (see (b)); and
the Act was approved on 11 April 2006 (see(b)). The Act was published in the
Government Gazette on 18 April 2006 (see (b)(1)).
Sometimes an Act becomes effective on the same date
as it is published in the
Government Gazette,
but at other times it is indicated in the Act when it will be
effective (see
sec. 98 of the Act).
Always make sure that an Act is effective
before
referring to it. If you are not sure you
should rather consult the Butterworth’s
publication ‘‘Is it in force?’’. Use the
number of the Act as well as the year in which it
was promulgated to find the relevant
information
Signed text: Before an Act can be
published, it has to be signed by the State President after
Parliament has approved it. In our example, the president signed the
English copy
of the Act. This means that whenever there is a dispute concerning
any part
of the Act, the English version will be the official version.
The short title of the Act is: the
Electronic Communications Act, 2005. (see (a) and sec 98 of the Act).The
long
title of the Act is the piece printed in bold under the word ACT (see (c)). The
long title
of an Act explains the purpose of the act. After the long title of the Act you will find
the ‘‘contents’’ of the Act in which it is indicated per
chapter which topics will receive attention .
Chapter 1, the Definitions (see (d)), is
extremely important. Not ALL the words in the Act are explained, but technical and
difficult terms or comprehensive phrases are explained. It
is important that the reader of the Act consults these
descriptions before he
or she
reads the Act. (Of cause you have to refer back to this section if you come
across
a word or phrase you do not understand.)
Acts are divided into Sections (see (e)),
subsections (see (f)), paragraphs (see (g)) and sub paragraphs (see (h)). This is to help you
understand the Act better and to help you with referencing. When you
reference it might read like this:
Sec 4(1)(a)(i) of Act 36 of 2005
How does one refer to an Act? (because legal
sources contain references to Acts, you have to read it correctly and understand
it; but you should also be able to write it correctly).
Any Act in South Africa has a name (the
short title, as explained above) plus a number and the year of publication. For example: the
Road Safety Act 29 of 1989.This
comprehensive
reference is usually used only the first time reference is made to the
Act.
When you refer to the same Act later you can simply refer to ‘‘the Act’’. For
example: the
Road Safety Act 29 of 1989 (herein after referred to as ‘‘the Act’’) it is
determined that
... .
Note there is no comma between the name
and number of the act. You can also refer to the number and year, for example: the
Prevention of Corruption Act 6 of 1959 or just Act 6 of 1959. An even shorter way is to abbreviate the
number and the year like this: Act 29/1989.
(b) Context
Apart from the text of an Act, you will
have to consider the context which gave rise to the Act as well. Section 39(2) of the Bill of
Rights in the Constitution says that a court, in interpreting any Act, has to take
cognisance of the spirit, purport and objects of the Bill of Rights.
The courts therefore sometimes recognise external
circumstances in
explaining the
reason the
Act came into being. They will investigate the reasons why the Act was
necessary.
They might therefore also consider the socio-economic and political or
historical scenario
in which the Act was formulated.
(c) Presumptions
Apart from the rules concerning the
interpretation of Acts as contained in the Interpretation Act
33 of 1957, certain presumptions must also be taken into account. For
example:
q Legislation
does not contain meaningless sections, every word and phrase therefore
has meaning.
q Legislation
doesn’t want to change existing laws unnecessarily.
q Unreasonable
or unfair consequences are not envisaged.
q Legislation
only applies in future and not retrospectively
The
structure of a reported decision
Here we are going to deal with the way in
which a case is set out or outlined. In other words we
are going to focus on the structure of a decision (or case).
Judges’ Names
The name(s) of the judge(s) appears
(appear) under the name of the court where the matter was heard. The letters that appear after
the names of the judges are not the initials of the
judges (or abbreviations of the judges’ first names). They indicate the title
of the
judge.
Thus, ‘‘J’’ stands for ‘‘Judge’’.
Up to November 2001, the titles of the
judges in the different courts were indicated as follows (the English is followed by the Afrikaans
version).
Constitutional
court
P — President (President)
DP/AP — Deputy President (Adjunkpresident)
J/R — Judge/Justice (Regter)
Supreme
Court of Appeal
CJ/HR — Chief Justice (Hoofregter)
DCJ/AHR — Deputy Chief Justice (Adjunkhoofregter)
JA/AR — Judge of Appeal (Appe`lregter)
AJA/WnAR — Acting Judge of Appeal (Waarnemende Appe`lregter)
The titles of the judges of
these courts
are now indicated as follows:
Constitutional
Court
CJ/HR — Chief Justice (Hoofregter)
DCJ/AHR — Deputy Chief Justice (Adjunkhoofregter)
J/R — Judge/Justice (Regter)
Supreme
Court of Appeal
P — President (President)
DP/AP — Deputy President (Adjunkpresident)
JA/AR — Judge of Appeal (Appe`lregter)
AJA/WnAR — Acting Judge of Appeal (Waarnemende Appe`lregter)
High Courts
JP/RP — Judge President (Regter-president)
DJP/AdjRP/ARP — Deputy Judge President (Adjunkregter-President)
J/R — Judge (Regter)
AJ/WnR — Acting Judge (Waarnemende Regter)
Note! that the titles of the judges of the High
Courts remain unchanged
to the position before Nov 2001
Headnotes
The headnote is a summary of the case. It
includes all the aspects of the case that the editor considers to be important. It
usually includes the area of law that the case is concerned with as well as the ratio (see
below) of the case. Some sentences in the headnote start
with the word ‘‘Held’’.
This word indicates a finding of the court. It
usually takes
the following structure or format: ‘‘The court held that ...’’. The head
note is useful
because it gives you an idea of what the case is all about. You should not
always rely
totally on the headnote because the editor’s summary
may be incomplete or
inaccurate.
Judgment
Look
at our examples again:
(1) S v Makua 1993 (1) SACR 160 (T)
Mahomed J: The appellant was found guilty in the
magistrate’s court at
Middelburg on a charge of contravening
...
(2) Molefe v Mahaeng 1999 (1) SA 562 (SCA)
Melunsky AJA: At about 11:00 on 11 August 1991
the appellant and the
respondent were driving their respective
motor vehicles in opposite directions ...
(3) Ex Parte Addleson 1948
(2) SA 16 (E)
Pittman JP: This is an application for
admission as an advocate and the provision of the
law, on which it is based, is sec. 1 of the Admission of Advocates
Amendment Act,
39 of 1946 ...
Most often the judgment will take the
following form:
(a) First, the facts are given.
(b) Second, there is a discussion of the
relevant legal principles.
(c) Third, the existing law is applied to
the facts of the case.
(d) Fourth, a decision is given in the
light of the relevant legal principles.
(e) Fifth, an order is given.
(f) Finally, an order regarding costs is
made
Different
kinds of judgments:
Majority judgments and etc
A case may sometimes be heard by more
than one judge. If the judges are in agreement, one judge
hands down the judgment. This judgment represents the opinion of all the
judges on
the bench.
Judges
may also disagree with one another, and when this happens
more than
one judgment can be handed down. We would, in such situations, get
different kinds
of judgments. We are now going to explain each of these judgments
briefly:
Majority
judgment
A majority judgment means that the
majority of judges who have heard a particular case give the same judgment based on the same
reasons. One judge gives the judgment and the others concur (agree) with it.
The ratio decidendi of the majority judgment creates
the precedent
to be used in future cases, and is binding.
Minority
judgment
The minute we speak of majority judgments
a suggestion is immediately made (that is, we imply) that there must also be cases in
which there are minority judgments. In a minority judgment the judge disagrees with the
majority and reaches a different
conclusion.
In such a case a judge differs from the
majority of judges as far as the judgment and
the reasons for the judgment are concerned. Such a judgment does not
establish a
precedent. It can, however, have persuasive force in the future. It is also
possible for a
judge to concur (or agree) with the minority judgment of another judge
Separate
judgment
Sometimes a judge does not disagree with
the conclusion of the other judges, but has different reasons
for his/her judgment. Any reasons added by the judge for his/her
judgment, do
not establish a precedent.
The ratio decidendi is only to be found in the
majority judgment
(These concepts will be explained thoroughly in the module
Introduction to
Law.) It is also possible for a judge to concur (agree) with the separate
judgement of
another judge.
You will notice that all our examples (the given
cases) cover majority judgments? In other words, one judge passed a particular
judgment and the others concurred (agreed)with it.
The
name(s) of the judge(s) that concurred appears/appear at
the end of the
judgment.
Look at our examples (cases):
(1) S v Makua 1993 (1) SACR 160 (T)
In this case there were two judges who
heard the matter, Mahomed J
handed down
judgment and
Goldstein J concurred. (See p. 164 of the case.)
(2) Molefe v Mahaeng 1999 (1) SA 562 (SCA)
In this case there were three judges who
heard the matter. Melunsky AJA handed
down judgment
and Hefer JA
and Zulman JA
concurred. (See p. 570 of the case.)
(3) Ex parte Addleson 1948
(2) SA 16 (E)
In this case there were two judges who
heard the matter. Pittman JP handed down judgment and
Gardner J concurred (see p. 18 of the case).
Order
of the court
S v Makua 1993 (1) SACR 160 (1)
‘‘In the result I would make the
following order:
1. The conviction of the appellant is
confirmed.
2. The sentence imposed by the magistrate
is set aside and substituted by the
following:
(a) The accused is sentenced to pay a
fine of R1 000.
(b) In addition to the fine the accused
is sentenced to six months’
imprisonment,
the whole of which is suspended for five years on the condition that the accused is not
convicted of contravening s122 of the Road Traffic Act 29 of 1989, or
any statutory
substitution thereof,
committed during the period of suspension.
(c) In terms of s 55(b) of Act 29 of 1989
the accused’s driving licence
is cancelled.’’
The
order as to costs
Lets refer to page 68 and read…
Reading
and understanding a journal article
If you have the name of an article as
well as the author you can find the article in the library but before
you start reading it, there are a few aspects to
consider:
• When
was the article published? (In other words how old is the article, is it relevant?
Was it
published before or after the new Constitution?)
• Who
is the author/writer of the article? Is he/she an authority on the topic? Has he/she
written
other articles in the same field as well?
The
structure of an article
A good article consists of the following:
•a
title
• an abstract
• an introduction
•
arguments
• conclusion
Reading
an article
• Read
the title as well as the abstract.
• Skim-read
the article.
• Read
the article again for detail.
• Read
the article again including the footnotes as the footnotes sometimes contain
valuable information.
Think
about the article and answer the following questions:
1.
Which
aspects is the author addressing and why?
2.
Which
solutions are given?
3.
Is it
relevant information that can make a difference?
4. Which sources are referenced and are they
authoritative?
NB! Remember, you
do not have to agree with an author, even if the author is an authority
on the specific topic. Try to get
different views on the same topic —footnotes can assist
you with this. Try to find articles
written by overseas writers on the same topic. If you
differ from what you have read you will
have to substantiate your arguments.
Once again, do not study this section
of Reading Skills in
isolation. You
cannot read
an Act, a court case, or an article without knowing where to find it. As we
go through the next
section on research skills to complete the
picture.
Good and clear explanations. Would like to know where and how to find the whole case.
ReplyDeletecan you please help me how to find the whole
ReplyDeleteI can see you've explained the whole case but am still struggling with summarising it in the following manner: The facts of the case,The legal question, Ratio decidendi and The decision of the court
ReplyDeletePlease help